The short answer is that the best acoustical underlay is the one that works for you, considering your budget, your substrate, the type of floor you’re installing over top, and of course, your strata.
The short answer is that the best acoustical underlay is the one that works for you, considering your budget, your substrate, the type of floor you’re installing over top, and of course, your strata.
Testing for sound is a complicated process. To produce meaningful results, you will need the services of an acoustical engineer.
Construction / Renovation recommendations
There are no magic solutions to prevent noise transfer. Quieter living habits are not easily regulated outside of noise curfews. Carpet floor coverings used to muffle noise are an obvious solution. This solution still will not eliminate all sounds such as creaking subfloor in old wood frame construction buildings.
What are the standards of the National Building Code (NBC)?
The National Building Code (NBC) sets out technical provisions prepared by the Canadian National Research Council (CNRC) to describe the construction minimum standards in Canada. The NBC describes the types of materials, their specifications and minimum performances they must deliver when used in construction.
In the case of acoustics for a multi family building of more than one floor, or in co-ownership, the NBC REGULATION for airborne noise as of 2015 was STC 50 for separating partitions. Since 2018, the ASTC 47 standards, which take flanking into consideration, are also accepted as a REGULATION measurement.
Impact noise (IIC) is not yet regulated. There is a RECOMMENDATION of an IIC 55.
This recommendation leaves a significant gap for performance and interpretation in the field.
Despite there being no requirements in the National Building Code about mitigation of impact noises, a certain level is necessary for the occupants’ comfort and satisfaction. Although it is impossible to build a condominium unit thoroughly soundproofed, it is possible to design and build a certain acoustical comfort that allows the occupants to live comfortably without the concern of disturbing neighbors or being bothered by them.
Click here for the National Building Code and go to Division B Section 5.8 Sound Transmission.
Yes. Common sense says dropping something or stepping on a soft surface will generate less noise than doing the same on a hard surface. In acoustics, carpet will always be a superior material for mitigating sound transference. Engineered hardwood, laminate, vinyl plank and ceramic/stone flooring installed over an acoustical membrane/underlayment all provide similar noise transference characteristics and do not compare to carpet. Carpet is often replaced by a hard surface flooring after a home sale and/or during renovations. Switching from soft to hard surface will dramatically change the noise levels of many normal lifestyle activities such as moving chairs, placing/dropping objects, talking and watching TV. Changing an existing floor covering should be carefully considered before going ahead or granting approval as it is important to research effective acoustical solutions specific to each building to ensure optimal performance for occupants and neighbours.
Delta IIC is another way to present a product’s performance. Ultimately, the number presented represents the product’s contribution in an assembly in a lab test. This value is obtained when tested in laboratory according to ASTM E2179 testing standards.
Yes, although concrete buildings have a great reputation for acoustic performances, they need specific attention also to ensure that flooring renovations are done properly and the right products are used to mitigate sound transmission.
Yes you can but beware. Making the transition from carpet flooring to hard surface flooring will have an impact on the acoustic performance of your building. Make sure you get help from experts to help you understand the implications and how to set a bylaw and standards.